4.1 Criteria
4.1.1 Noise Floor
The steady-state
theatre noise floor should preferably be below NC25, with NC30 the worst case
acceptable. Intermittent increased noise floors should not exceed
NC35.
Dolby SR and SRD sound-tracks can contain very quiet
sounds, as well as louder peaks than conventional film sound-tracks. Playback
of these subtle components requires extra attention to background noise levels
in the theatre.
Background noises can be broken into two types: steady-state
noise, caused by HVAC equipment, refrigerators, projector noise and distant
traffic rumble; and intermittent noise, caused by adjacent traffic noise,
aircraft noise, footfall and adjacent screen breakthrough.
Figure 4.1 details the frequency characteristics of a family of
NC curves in the range of interest. It should be noted that these curves show
the NC figures for noise measurements made in whole octave bands, as
conventionally used for background noise measurements. Figure 4.2 shows a
family of curves for use in third-octave bands.
Normal techniques for background noise measurements are intended
to quantify steady-state noises, and may not adequately define the annoyance of
"chatter" noise, such as running projectors. Such noises should be subjectively
inaudible in the seating area.
Reference: SMPTE RP141 -- Background Acoustic Noise Levels
4.1.2 Reverberation Time
The reverberation
characteristic for a theatre should be within the ranges shown in Figures 4.3
and 4.4.
Certain acoustic parameters differ depending whether a space is
intended for music performance (a concert hall, or film sound-track
reproduction (a cinema). The most obvious of these is reverberation, which in
the cinema should be effectively as low as possible, and in the concert hall
may consciously be extended in the design, to improve the subjective loudness
of the music, and to make a more pleasant sound. In the cinema, the
prime requirement is a more accuuate sound; reverberation needed to make the
sound more pleasant is added during the mix during sound-track
production. As most dubbing theatres are now moderately small, with short
reverberation times, the mix will add adequate reverberation for all replay
theatres.
Within reason, the reverberation characteristic of a theatre
should be as short as possible. Excessive reverberation results in coloring of
the sound and reduced intelligibility of the dialog. Assuming a theatre is
built with sound absorbent material on all surfaces, the resultant
reverberation characteristic will increase with room size, in consequence of
greater reflection time delays caused by increased path lengths.
Figure 4.4 shows the acceptable range of reverberation time change with frequency. This is a scaling curve, and the value at a given frequency should be multiplied by the optimum reverberation time at 500 Hz found from Figure
4.3 (1)
4.1.3 Reflections
Optimization of
reverberation time, though, is not enough to ensure good acoustics. A good
theatre design will also avoid resonances and reflections. Good practice
dictates that the front of the loudspeaker wall should be heavily damped with
sound absorbing material, and even more important, that the rear wall of the
auditorium should be heavily damped. Any theatres still using A4 type
loudspeakers with wings should apply sound absorbing material to the front
surface. Acoustically absorbent material can be added to an existing theatre,
but new theatre designs should also consider issues such as minimum port glass
size ( see below), as too large a glass area in
the projection room wall can cause both picture and sound-reflection problems.
Other sound reflection problems can come from converted old theatres with
proscenium arches which face the screen, and ceiling beams and vertical column
faces reflecting sound from the screen.
4.1.4 Early Lateral Reflections
Another difference in
acoustic requirements between cinema and concert halls relates to the
desirability of early lateral reflections (sounds that reflect off the side
walls at the front of the auditorium). In a concert hall, with a music
performance, these reflections can be attractive, adding to stereo width, and
giving the music more "body". But the same effect with dialog in a cinema can
be disastrous to speech intelligibility, as the central speech image becomes
diffuse, and there are multiple delayed reflections. For this reason, the side
walls at the front of a cinema should be as absorbent as possible, and the
loudspeakers should have a spatial response tailored to minimise the amount of
signal which can hit the side walls (especially at frequencies above, say,
500Hz). The controlled directivity from use of horns is the only practical way
this can be achieved. Direct radiator cone loudspeakers are not suitable for
stage loudspeaker use, as not only will energy be reflected off the side-walls,
but signals will also be reflected off the ceiling, further muddying dialog
clarity.
4.1.5 Rear Screen Damping
No behind-screen
acoustic reflections should be audible in the seating area.
Behind screen echoes have historically been responsible for many
of the intelligibility problems with cinema sound. The most effective method of
achieving screen front/back isolation is to mount the loudspeakers as integral
elements within a well-damped wall; this will block all but the lowest
frequency back-screen audio. The front surface should be covered with acoustic
absorbent material, damping any front/back reflections in the auditorium.
A wall also creates a perfect plane baffle, as described in
classic loudspeaker design literature, thus significantly improving extreme
low-frequency response and linearity. This is one of the reasons that a
loudspeaker wall is one of the major elements of the THX loudspeaker
system.
Without an isolation wall, attenuation of behind-screen
reflections becomes much more difficult. The first and most obvious requirement
is that the high- frequency horns should be mounted as close as possible to the
rear of the projection screen, minimizing acoustic reflections off the screen
surface itself. (The front of the horn should never be more than an inch or two
from the screen.) Next, each loudspeaker assembly should be draped with
substantial acoustically absorbent material, wrapping the entire assembly up
against the screen. Finally, as much of the cavity surface area behind the
screen as possible -- rear wall, side-walls and ceiling -- should be covered in
absorbent material.One further consideration relating to systems without a
loudspeaker wall is that the front surface of any large area bass bins, (and
even more important, if fitted, the speaker wings), should have absorbent
material mounted on front surfaces with cut-outs for the woofers. Without such
material, significant reflective ''ping-pong" echoes can build up between the
screen and the parallel rear wall of the theatre.
4.2 New Theatre
Design
Interior acoustics are
Excess reflected sound of most importance for dialog intelligibility. can
result in flutter echoes or reverberation which diminishes dialogue
intelligibility.
It is not necessary to provide specific sound-reflecting
surfaces in motion picture theatres. Most of the surfaces can be
sound-absorbing. Some might argue that it would become difficult to sustain
adequate loudness; suitable modern power amplifiers and loudspeakers, however,
can easily be selected which provide enough power. Experience indicates that
sound-absorbing rooms promote excellent speech intelligibility provided they
are reasonably quiet.
Sound-absorbing material can be used to reduce reverberation and
control echoes. Standing waves can result in low-frequency room resonance's
which accentuate a "boomy" quality. Standing waves can be controlled using
sound-absorbing material with an air space behind, such as a lay-in
ceiling.
4.2.1 New Theatre Location
Select a quiet location
to reduce the costs of construction to prevent noise intrusions. Areas and
adjacencies to avoid:
a) Next to window glazing.
b) Building service areas such
as toilets, mechanical rooms, electrical rooms and elevator equipment
rooms.
c) Other noise generating adjacencies.
Remember to review the use of spaces above and below the theatre
for potential noise generation. Avoid locations beneath equipment rooms, and
dance and exercise studios, or above parking garages or subway train lines.
Airport flight paths, truck loading areas, and busy traffic intersections
should also be considered during site selection, as the increased cost of
adequate sound isolation may be significant.
Never locate a theatre below a curb-mounted air handler with
direct bottom inlet and discharge, unless the ductwork is fury enclosed in
special sound attenuation construction.
4.2.2 Ceilings
In order to avoid
excessive bass, specify a lay-in ceiling with soundabsorbing tiles having an
NRC rating of 0.90 or greater. The tiles are typically comprised of 1.5" thick
fiberglass with a painted glass cloth facing.
4.2.3 Floors
Unless absolutely
impossible, aisles and floors should always be carpeted.
4.2.4 Walls
Sound Transmission Design Criteria
Walls, doors and floor/ceiling constructions are rated for their
sound transmission properties according to ASTM Standards E90, E336, and C413
which result in a single figure of merit rating system known as Sound
Transmission Class, or STC.
The selection of appropriate STC ratings needs to be made on the
basis of the background noise criteria selected in the theatre and the level of
noise anticipated in the adjoining spaces. Continuous background noise can play
an important role in perceived sound isolation by masking transmitted sound.
The sum of the STC rating plus NC rating should always equal or exceed 95 at
common walls between theatres. Other sources of intrusive noise should be
evaluated.
All sound-rated partitions must incorporate full height
slab-tostructure framing containing fibrous insulation and gypsum board sealed
airtight at the head and sill with a bead of acoustic sealant. All penetrations
must be sealed airtight and recessed boxes fully enclosed. Four-gang and
smaller junction boxes can be sealed using sheet caulking on the back and
sides, as shown in Figure 4.5. Larger boxes can be effectively sealed using
one-hour fire-rated gypsum board construction. Comply with the standards
outlined in ASTM Standard E447, "installation of Fixed Partitions of Light
Frame Type for the Purpose of Conserving Their Sound Insulation Efficiency.
Figure 4.6 shows minimal and typical multiplex demising wall
designs necessary to achieve acceptable auditorium isolation.
Table 2 below presents suitable STC ratings. Note that higher
numerical STC ratings transmit less sound, and higher NC ratings permit louder
background sound due to the ventilation system.
Table 2: STC Ratings for Common Walls Between Theatres
Minimum in-situ STC Rating Noise Criteria Description STC 60 NC 35 Minimum
Standard STC 65 NC 30 Typical STC 70 NC 25 Desirable
In order to avoid sound "flanking" the walls, continuous metal
roof decks are discouraged without gypsum board ceilings, and independent floor
slabs with an elastic joint are required at STC 65 and greater walls.
Figure 4.7 shows a more sophisticated wall design, used to
ensure isolation between projection rooms and auditorium -- a construction of
this type can be a major element in isolating projector and machinery room
noise.
Sound-Absorbing Wall Treatments
The wall behind the audience should be covered in
sound-absorbing material entirely.
Typical sound-absorbing panels are comprised of 1.5" thick
glass- fibercore wrapped in porous fabric having inherent flame-resistant
properties. Panels are available with fabric edge wrapped conditions and with
resin hardened edges, metal, or wood frames. Complete prefabricated
sound-absorbing panels are available.
If the side walls are not angled, avoid hard flat parallel
gypsum board surfaces facing one another across the room, particularly in the
audience area at ear height, in order to avoid flutter echoes.
1 Reverberation time measurement techniques are
discussed in IS03382.